Publishing houses and self published authors sometimes change the covers on their books. Many do so to keep up with changing trends in the book marketplace. As reader tastes change, so do book covers. Below are some examples of different covers for award winning books by Karen Cushman, and a brief synopsis of each book to help you analyze the cover. Catherine, Called Birdy is a novel written as a diary. It begins in September 1290, with Catherine describing her father's manor, her parents, and the world she lives in. Her father wishes her to marry someone who will make advantageous social connections, but all the suitors he brings fall short of Birdy's ideal. Finally, Catherine's father demands her to marry an old, repulsive man whom she calls "Shaggy Beard." She refuses, and devises many scenarios to escape. As the day for Catherine's official betrothal approaches, she realizes that she herself will be the same no matter who she marries. However, Shaggy Beard dies and she is pleased to become engaged to his clean, young, educated son. The Midwife's Apprentice tells the story of a homeless, nameless orphan girl. Called Brat, the only name she can remember anyone calling her, she sleeps in dung heaps to keep warm until a harsh and uncaring midwife named Jane Sharp takes her in as an apprentice. She takes on the new name of Alyce and begins to grow as she learns skills, but eventually runs away from the midwife. While away, she learns to read and write and discovers that she truly has a calling to be a midwife. She returns to Jane Sharp's service determined to learn. Just this week, the wonderful middle grade author Karen Cushman posted a link to an article written by the woman who is creating the cover for her newest book. Jamie Zollars explains the process she went through, and it is fascinating and well worth reading. Grayling's Song is Cushman's first fantasy novel, and as such the cover needed to be very different. Jennifer Bohnhoff is a writer that lives in central New Mexico. Her books On Fledgling Wings, the story of a motherless young boy in medieval England who wishes to become a knight to help himself feel more worthy, is on sale on Amazon now through December 8. You can read about the author and her books on her website.
14 Comments
12/6/2021 10:04:25 am
Covers can make such a huge difference to young readers, and 1980s and 1990s covers were particularly unattractive, for some reason. I like the more cartoon style illustrations on modern tales, but they don't seem right for historical ones. Years ago, there was a blog that focused solely on the covers of MG and YA books, but it's no longer around. I miss it! Thanks for sharing these.
Reply
12/8/2021 11:23:05 am
I like the oldest of the covers in each case. I see the misery of Brat in the first one, and that sums up so much of the story. The others, by comparison, seem pretty banal. Glad you agree with me.
Reply
12/6/2021 10:33:36 am
It's so interesting that some covers have been changed more than once. I wouldn't have thought publishers would change them so many times.
Reply
12/8/2021 11:25:15 am
Is this yet another example of how everything has to be new and shiny these days? We go from one thing to another so quickly.
Reply
12/6/2021 05:34:06 pm
I often like the older covers but can see the appeal for young people with the new ones. I also usually like the U.S. version of a cover better after they were first published overseas, Thanks for the interesting post and for joining us on MMGM today.
Reply
12/8/2021 11:24:11 am
So glad I could add to the conversation! Thanks for having me.
Reply
Completely Full Bookshelf
12/6/2021 09:37:56 pm
Welcome to MMGM, Jennifer—this is a fascinating post! I love thinking about book covers (I actually blogged about them a few months back on my blog), and it's neat to trace the evolution of Cushman's (even though I haven't had the chance to read any of these beloved stories). I tend to prefer modern covers because they're what I grew up with, although I do wonder how well they fit with the contents of some of these newer books.
Reply
12/8/2021 11:27:04 am
I'll have to hunt down your blog and look at the covers you reviewed. It's interesting stuff - how we present our ideas to the world. Glad you liked this. Thanks.
Reply
12/8/2021 12:27:12 am
We all judge books by their covers, though we are loathe to admit it. I can't resist a good cover. I tend to like the older covers. I find they are usually more artistic. Thanks for an interesting post. Welcome to MMGM.
Reply
12/8/2021 11:28:24 am
Thanks for the welcome. I can't believe it took me so long to find such a dynamic group of mg supporters. I learn so much from you!
Reply
Terry Nichols
12/8/2021 02:27:28 pm
I definitely like the older covers. The more recent cartoonish covers seem to trivialize the contents--for me, anyway. Great post, Jennifer!
Reply
Jennifer Bohnhoff
12/11/2021 11:58:48 am
Glad you liked it, Terry!
Reply
12/8/2021 04:29:03 pm
Welcome to MMGM! I like all the covers, really. But understand that they have to appeal to the age group/audience. Thanks for sharing Catherine, Called Birdy! It reminds me of a medieval tale of courage.
Reply
12/11/2021 11:58:19 am
I love Catherine Called Birdy! Lovely book with a feisty female.
Reply
Leave a Reply. |
ABout Jennifer BohnhoffI am a former middle school teacher who loves travel and history, so it should come as no surprise that many of my books are middle grade historical novels set in beautiful or interesting places. But not all of them. I hope there's one title here that will speak to you personally and deeply. Categories
All
Archives
November 2024
|
|